August 27, 2026
In February 2025, a couple closed on a corner lot, across the street from Washington Park itself. The price was $2.6 million for 11,600 square feet and an aging house they planned to replace with a family home. By May they had finished architectural plans and filed for a demolition permit. By June, two groups of neighbors, 24 people between them, had sent the city letters about turning the old house into a protected landmark instead.
"We'd never heard of this process, and unfortunately, there was nothing disclosed on the sale about it," one of the buyers told CBS Colorado that summer. "We found out that the previous owner had gone through this process. We would have never bought the property if it would have been disclosed."
The buyers' story played out over roughly four months, ending with the house coming down. For anyone considering an older lot in Wash Park, the useful takeaway is how the city's review process works, whether or not a property becomes the subject of a designation application.
Here's what the buyers were working with once the dispute started. They had paid $2.6 million for the property. According to the county assessor, the structure itself was valued at $1,000. The rest was land.
The formal landmark application carried an $875 fee.
BusinessDen reported the buyer's account of the fee. A landmark review can affect a buyer's redevelopment plans after closing. Buyers considering a teardown can ask the city about a parcel's history before making an offer.
Denver's landmark ordinance addresses concerns about buildings slated for demolition, and Denverite reports that a formal designation application has historically needed the backing of at least three city residents to move forward. Historic Denver says that once an owner files a demolition permit or a Certificate of Demolition Eligibility, city staff has ten business days to decide whether the structure could plausibly meet landmark criteria. If it might, the city posts a public notice at the property and notifies the neighborhood association and nearby council members.
There's a version of this process that runs in the buyer's favor instead. The Certificate of Demolition Eligibility isn't only a same-day precursor to knocking a building down. Denver's own preservation office and Historic Denver both describe it as a due-diligence tool a prospective buyer can use before closing, if the current owner is willing to sign and submit it. A clean certificate gives an owner, and by extension a buyer, a five-year window to demolish without repeating the review. The catch is that only the current owner can apply
The property wasn't a first-time flashpoint. In 2021, its then-owner, Aaron Grant of Grant Real Estate Co., applied for a demolition permit on the same house. Neighbors pushed to have it landmarked. A city-hired mediator brought both sides together, and they struck a deal: Grant withdrew the demolition application, the residents agreed not to file for landmark status, and the house stayed standing. Grant sold the property in February 2025 for $2.6 million to the buyers, who say they had no idea any of that history existed.
Nothing in the sale flagged it.
Denver preservation watchers describe something close to a repeatable pattern on properties like this one: an owner wants to demolish, neighbors say the building deserves protection, the owner offers to sell to anyone willing to preserve it, an agent lists it, and if no preservation buyer materializes, the argument that preservation isn't viable gets stronger. A Dutch Colonial Revival in City Park West went the other direction and was designated a landmark in 2023. A home on Montview in South Park Hill was demolished after the Landmark Preservation Commission rejected a neighbor-led application to save it. Wash Park's concentration of homes built before the neighborhood's platting and its lots that back directly onto the park make it exactly the kind of inventory where this dynamic tends to surface, since scarcity is what makes these lots worth fighting over in the first place.
The neighbors' formal application, filed in late August 2025 by three residents named Debs, Stefanie Jacobs, and Susan Holbrook, argued the house was one of the earliest surviving structures in East Washington Park and a well-preserved example of Free Classic Queen Anne architecture, tied to a former Denver County and District judge who once lived there. The buyers' attorneys countered that the home had been altered repeatedly over the decades, that repair estimates ran past $1.3 million just to make it habitable, and that it sat back from the street among a block of homes that had almost all already been rebuilt.
The Landmark Preservation Commission held its hearing on September 16, 2025. The vote came back 3 to 3, which meant the designation failed. The dispute ended roughly four months after they first applied for the demolition permit.
A 3-3 vote is close enough that it could have gone the other way. Anyone treating an older home's low assessed value as proof the land is unencumbered is reading the wrong number. Before you write an offer on a property you intend to redevelop:
If you're weighing a purchase anywhere near the park with this kind of upside in mind, our East Wash Park neighborhood guide covers the broader context of what's driving pricing and demand in the surrounding blocks.
Does a seller have to disclose a past landmark dispute? In the buyers' case, nothing about the 2021 fight surfaced during their purchase. Rather than relying on disclosure to catch this, ask the city's preservation staff directly about a parcel's history before you close.
Can one neighbor file to landmark a property on their own? A formal designation application has historically required at least three city residents to bring it forward, though the demolition posting itself can be triggered by staff review alone once an owner applies for a permit or certificate.
How long should I expect this to take if it happens? The timeline ran from the buyers' May demolition-permit application to the September hearing, close to four months.
Buying a distinctive or aging home in Wash Park often means buying a piece of the neighborhood's history along with the lot. Sometimes that history can affect a buyer's plans, even if the buyer learns about it only after closing. If you're considering a purchase where the land, not the structure, is the point, The David Bell Group can help you check that history before you're the one explaining it to your own family.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
David Bell is a seasoned Denver real estate professional with a rich background in finance, marketing, and operations, and over $150 million in sales since 2013. A Denver native and former CPA, David brings sharp business acumen from his career with global fashion brands and fitness companies, now pairing it with his passion for real estate to deliver exceptional client experiences. Known for his professionalism, integrity, and personal touch, he helps clients navigate life transitions with ease—whether buying, selling, or finding the right resources for their homes. Working alongside his sister, Nancy Jones, at Milehimodern, David is proud to combine hometown roots with world-class expertise in Denver’s dynamic real estate market.
📍 44 Cook St., #310, Denver, CO 80206
📞 (303) 887-1358
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
November 19, 2026
November 12, 2026
November 5, 2026
October 29, 2026
October 22, 2026
October 15, 2026
October 8, 2026
October 1, 2026
September 24, 2026
The David Bell Group at Milehimodern are expert Denver real estate agents dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. Contact us today to start your home searching journey!